Outsourcing In The Airline Industry Means Death!!

Author: August 12, 2012 10:00 am

Attention All Passengers” is the name of his new book. The author is none other than William McGee.

William McGee is a former airlines operations manager who has made a career as an aviation journalist, writing for Consumer Reports and other publications. He’s an FAA-licensed aircraft dispatcher and in 2010 was named the sole consumer advocate to the Future of Aviation Advisory Committee, formed to make recommendations to the Department of Transportation.

In an interview on NPR, McGee outlined what he has encountered in the outsourcing of Airline repairs and maintenance that is quite startling:

“Aircraft maintenance and repairs are also frequently outsourced — in some cases to unlicensed mechanics in China, Singapore, Mexico and El Salvador.”

“In my view, it’s a critical safety issue — the FAA’s lack of oversight of maintenance [in these countries]. It used to be, if an airline had a major maintenance facility, the FAA had an office, and an inspector could pop by anytime [to monitor the repairs]. Now, with work being done [overseas], I’ve had dozens of inspectors express their frustration that they can’t do their jobs. They’re [FAA] monitoring this work on an honor system.”

McGee also reported that mechanics have approached him with concerns about these planes flight status, and that when the planes return they are not ready to fly.

“Among the problems they’ve talked about are doors that were not sealed properly… There are problems with engines that have had to be shut down, and there are serious problems that have led to smoke in the cabin,” he says. “And any time you have smoke in the cabin, that could lead to catastrophe. These airplanes are coming back in conditions where additional work needs to be done to get them back online, in many cases.”

“The Federal Aviation Administration does not require airlines to list the subcontractors they work with. And finding out that information can be quite difficult…”Independent government organizations, including the Government Accountability Office and the Department of Transportation’s Inspector General’s Office, have gone to the airlines and said, ‘Where is the work being done and who’s doing it?.’ And the airlines, amazingly, have responded that they’re not clear, in some cases. To me, this is just mind-boggling. … Congressional testimony has shown that the FAA does not even have a full sense of where the work is being done.” says McGee.

Any of these problems can cause fatal results while flying at 30,000 feet, McGee went on to name two crashes that the FAA identified improper maintenance and repairs as a primary cause.

One of these crashes was ‘ValuJet Flight 592…

This from the NYTimes:

Valenzuela was a mechanic for the now-defunct airline maintenance contractor SabreTech, the focus of what became the first ever criminal prosecution over a U.S. airline crash.

The NTSB reported that allegedly Valenzuela helped gain certification on a set of cabin oxygen generators, falsifying the documentation to show that they had been properly removed and replaced. As a result of the generators being loaded on to ValuJet Flight 592 without the proper markings, safety caps, packaging and other safety measures, they played a key role in the fire which caused the crash.

It was also noted in the report that ValuJet failed to oversee the contractors involved to make sure full hazardous materials compliance.

McGee went on to say that the subcontracting companies that the repair jobs are outsourced to, in turn went on to outsource the job to another set of unqualified people not licensed in America or the Foreign countries where the work eventually takes place.

He added that in one instance, a surfboard shop was given the job to work on an Airplane body part that contained similar materials common to both surfboards and the Airplane’s parts. Fortunately the FAA caught that one before the suspect components were used in the maintenance of an airplane.

Even though the FAA maintains that there are industry standards that are being adhered to by the large Commercial Airplane companies, an extra level of problems arise when these large carriers contract smaller regional fliers to handle smaller pieces of the flight from one destination to another, via connecting flights.

Mr. McGee added that these smaller regional fliers do not observe the industry standards as well as the larger carriers and while the FAA says only one large flight went down in recent times, that being the Rockaways, New York  crash which killed 265 passengers, crew and people on the ground, there were at least six crashes by the smaller regional carriers during that same time period.

It is now the industry norm to have connecting flights in certain areas, that are not handled with the main carrier’s fleet of planes.

It is no secret that President Reagan was instrumental in the aviation industry being gutted to its core, starting with his firing of Air Traffic Controllers.  This single act gave the Airline industry the teeth it needed to shrink workers’ salaries and the industry’s safety oversight, in one sweep.

As a result, many pilots have had to deal with their salaries being reduced dramatically, while the rest of the industry has had to endure similar cutbacks, all to bolster stock prices of the Airlines. This no doubt has had an effect on the industry by them not being able to woo the more highly qualified pilots and mechanics, who prefer to earn better salaries in private jet companies in the US and globally.  In such an environment, how many airlines are seeking to cut corners even further?

Free download, 80% of “Shock and Awe on America” in different E-book formats at Smashwords.com get sale price of $2.99 with code GQ44M 


facebook comments:

1 Comment

  • This entire article is woefully incorrect and the fact that someone who isn’t even a pilot is fearmongering like this is outrageous. Outsourcing has little to nothing to do with aviation accidents. Aside from sabotage, there is never one single cause for any air crash and anyone who says otherwise has only the knowledge of aviation that a wikipedia article provided. The only crash that could be remotely linked to outsourced maintenance is the ValuJet crash, but the improper installation of the oxygen generators was only one of several factors that brought that aircraft down. Consequently, regulation of outsourced maintenance and the design and installation of oxygen generators was increased in the wake of this crash.
    Almost all regional carriers are wholly owned and operated by larger mainline or “Legacy” carriers and are required to abide by the exact same maintenance rules as every transport category aircraft, including being on a continual aircraft maintenance program (CAMP) which is certified by the FAA for each carrier. Accidents involving regional aircraft generally stem from inexperienced pilots and conditions at the smaller airports the operate into, not from inadequate or improper maintenance procedures.
    As a member of the aviation industry I can say without question that this industry is nowhere near being “gutted to the core”. That is a blatant lie. The FAA is in the process of upgrading the entire airspace system of the nation in its NextGen projet, and commercial air traffic is growing every year. The aviation industry is one of the most virulent in this country and contributes untold ssums to the economy. The industry did not reduce safety oversight in the slightest manor since it does not have the power to do so. The FAA regulates every aspect of aircraft maintenance, for good reason, and airlines have no choice but to abide by the strictest safety standards on the planet.
    As a commerical pilot myself I can personally say that pilots do not write off commercial airlines because of the low salary. Aviation is in your blood, it’s something that infiltrates your very being. If you go through the training in order to become a commercial pilot, you do not make choices based on money. There is no pilot who would “shy away” from a job at United simply because the pay was low.
    Airlines do not, and cannot cut corners on safety. There is a reason that the US has the safest airspace in the world. It’s because safety in engrained into every aspect of flight. From the moment someone enters the industry “safety” is the only thing they hear and the only thing that matters. This has been a progression over the past century hat builds off of every mistake made to create and even safer system.
    I know I’m forgetting points I wanted to make, but I simply couldn’t sit here and let someone with absolutely ZERO knowledge of my industry vilify it and make it seem as if the safety of every flying passenger is not the top priority. This article was a half hearted attempt at stirring up fear that was incorrect,in poor taste, and awful grammar.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.